Report looks to influence WEEE revision

Report looks to influence WEEE revision

By Jake Thomas, Resource Recycling

With the European Union on the verge of revising its WEEE directive, makeITfair, a group seeking to call attention to environmental damage that waste electronics can cause, has released a report highlighting the problems of e-waste flowing from Europe to Ghana.

The report, titled What a Waste, has found that around 600 containers of obsolete electronics are shipped to the West African country each month, with the U.K., Belgium, the Netherlands, Denmark, Italy and Spain among the top exporters.

"For a small part of the population, the import of used electronics is a lucrative business, but for the majority of the people involved in the e-waste industry it is a matter of survival," reads a statement from the organization. "Thousands of people are working in the informal waste industry in Ghana, where children constitute around 40 percent of scrap workers."

Although, the report notes that authorities in Ghana are aware of the problem and its scale, they've done little to address it aside from a modest recycling initiative.

Along with the Basel Action Network, the European Environmental Bureau and the Good Electronics Network, makeITfair is calling on the European Council to take three concrete steps:

First, they want the directive to remove all recently proposed exceptions that will allow untested, used electronics to be considered non-waste. Second, the organizations want the directive to include ambitious green design requirements. Third, a WEEE fee structure should be established to reflect different product properties.

The European Council could take action on the EU's WEEE Recast as soon as December.

CRC Banner

To return to the newsletter, click here

Comments

Report does not claim "obsolete"

This report, which I read last night, nowhere claims that the 600 containers imported into Ghana contained "obsolete" electronics.  While it claims it is "uncontrollabel" and "ewaste", the report nowhere challenges the more serious April Ghana report which showed that 85% of used electronics imported over a 2 year period were in fact working or repaired.

From this report:

 

"Conclusion:  As this report shows, there is an uncontrollable flow of second-hand electronic goods and e-waste into Ghana. Great Britain, 
Belgium, the Netherlands, Denmark, Italy and Spain are the top seven exporters of used computers to Ghana. Whether the 
computers are functioning or obsolete is uncertain. But due to the lack of recycling facilities, they will, no matter what, end 
up at dumpsites in Ghana and create pollution and health problems. "
 
As will brand new electronics, eventually.  
 
Earlier in the report there is the quote "...'And we discovered that the things that were brought into the country for reuse actually in some cases was obsolete goods disguised as usable,' says John Pwamang"   This does not actually disagree with the 15% in the SBC report.
 
Calling this report a "study" is a bit of a stretch.  Several pages are health manuals copied from another publication.  For a serious inquiry into used electroincs import policy in Africa, see SBC's "Ghana's E-Waste Country Assessment", which actually tracks domestically (Ghana) generated electronics like those found at the Agbogbloshie scrap site.  http://ewasteguide.info/files/Amoyaw-Osei_2011_GreenAd-Empa.pdf summary http://retroworks.blogspot.com/2011/04/new-report-coming-out-from-ghana.html

.

.